Nuts, Seeds & Butters

Nut and seed butters with gestational diabetes: the tablespoon, the label and the reduced-fat trap

A tablespoon of peanut butter carries about 3.6 g of carbohydrate, 3.6 g of protein and 95 kcal: USDA weighs a tablespoon of peanut, almond or cashew butter at 16 g, and the figure per 100 g describes a sixth of a jar. This guide takes the 16 nut and seed butters in the category and works at that scale; the Nuts, Seeds & Butters guide compares six of them per 100 g and explains what the salt and sugar claims on a jar mean. It then covers the products that change those numbers: reduced-fat peanut butter, which carries more carbohydrate than the regular kind, powdered peanut butter, which is peanut flour, and palm oil, which the ingredient list has to name. One butter here carries a pregnancy rule, Brazil nut butter, for the same selenium reason as the nut.

See what works for you. Try SugarCurve free for 7 days 

16 foodsLast reviewed: September 12, 2026Sources

Walnut Butter
Hemp Seed Butter
Pumpkin Seed Butter
Almond Butter

How these were chosen

The nut butters with the least carbohydrate, the seed butters with the most protein, macadamia for what its energy shows, and Brazil nut butter for its rule. Peanut butter and tahini are featured in the Nuts, Seeds & Butters guide; chestnut spread is a sweet spread and isn't featured.

What to look for

  1. A tablespoon is 16 g

    USDA weighs a tablespoon of peanut, almond or cashew butter at 16 g. At this library's figures, a spoon of peanut butter is 3.6 g of carbohydrate and 3.6 g of protein; of almond butter 3.4 g and 3.4 g; of cashew butter 4.9 g of carbohydrate, the most of the common butters; of walnut butter 1.8 g. Each spoon carries 95 to 115 kcal, because every butter here is 46 to 76 g fat per 100 g. Two spoons on toast is a normal serving, and 190 to 230 kcal.[1] [2]

  2. Reduced-fat peanut butter carries more carbohydrate

    USDA lists regular smooth peanut butter at 22.3 g of carbohydrate and 51.4 g of fat per 100 g, and reduced-fat peanut butter at 35.7 g of carbohydrate and 34 g of fat, with 540 mg of sodium against 426 mg. The fat that is taken out is replaced, and the carbohydrate rises by 13 g per 100 g. There is no reduced-fat butter in this library, so the comparison is USDA's alone; for gestational diabetes it is the one label word that moves the number that matters in the wrong direction.[1]

  3. Powdered peanut butter is peanut flour

    Products sold as powdered peanut butter are peanuts with most of the oil pressed out, so USDA's defatted peanut flour is the reference: 34.7 g of carbohydrate, 52 g of protein and 0.55 g of fat per 100 g, against 22.3 g, 22.2 g and 51.4 g for peanut butter. Per spoon, that means more carbohydrate and protein and almost no fat. Check the ingredient list for added sugar and salt.[1]

  4. Palm oil has to be named

    Under the EU's food information rules, refined vegetable oils may be grouped as 'vegetable oils' on an ingredient list only when the specific origin follows immediately, so a jar that contains palm oil says palm. The nutrition panel won't show it: added oil and the nut's own fat both land on the same fat line, so the ingredient list is where the difference lives.[3]

  5. The sugar line shows the nut's own sugar

    The butters here carry 1.4 to 8 g of sugar per 100 g, which is the sugar of the nut or seed itself: pistachio butter 8 g, peanut butter 5.9 g, almond butter 4.9 g, hemp and pumpkin seed butters 1.4 to 1.5 g. All but pistachio and peanut sit at or under the NHS's 5 g threshold for low sugar. A jar showing 10 g or more has had sugar added; chestnut spread, at 48 g, is a sweet spread and not a nut butter at all.[4]

  6. Salt by the spoon, and Brazil nut butter

    USDA's salted peanut butter carries 426 mg of sodium per 100 g, so a 16 g spoon carries about 68 mg; its reduced-sodium version 203 mg, about 32 mg a spoon; the unsalted butters here 3 to 17 mg, against the NHS's 6 g of salt a day. Brazil nut butter is marked limit for the same reason as the nut: selenium, which the NHS says causes selenosis in excess, against the 60 µg a day women need.[1] [5] [6]

Side by side

Nut butters, by carbohydrate

Per 100 g
FoodCarbsProteinCaloriesBlood sugar impact
Walnut Butter
11.3 g15.1 g688 kcallow
Macadamia Nut Butter
13.8 g7.9 g718 kcallow
Pecan Butter
13.9 g9.2 g710 kcallow
Hazelnut Butter
17.2 g15.1 g635 kcallow
Almond Butter
21.2 g21.1 g614 kcallow
Cashew Butter
30.5 g17.5 g594 kcallow

From 11 g of carbohydrate per 100 g in walnut butter to 30.5 g in cashew butter; macadamia carries the most energy.

Seed butters

Per 100 g
FoodCarbsFiberProteinBlood sugar impact
Hemp Seed Butter
8.7 g4 g31.5 glow
Pumpkin Seed Butter
14.7 g6 g30.2 glow
Watermelon Seed Butter
15 g5 g28 glow
Sunflower Seed Butter
23.5 g6.2 g19.8 glow
Flaxseed Butter
29 g27.1 g18.5 glow

Hemp and pumpkin seed butters carry about 30 g of protein per 100 g; flaxseed butter's 29 g of carbohydrate is 27 g fibre.

By protein

Per 100 g
FoodProteinCarbsFatBlood sugar impact
Hemp Seed Butter
31.5 g8.7 g49 glow
Pumpkin Seed Butter
30.2 g14.7 g49.1 glow
Watermelon Seed Butter
28 g15 g51 glow
Peanut Butter
22.5 g22.3 g51 glow
Almond Butter
21.1 g21.2 g55.5 glow
Pistachio Butter
21 g27 g50 glow

The seed butters lead on protein; peanut and almond butter sit together at about 22 g and 21 g.

Figures from each food's entry in this library. Open a food for its full profile and portion notes.

All foods in Nut Butters

16 foods in this category, each rated for glycemic impact and blood sugar effect.

Track how nut butters affects your blood sugar with the SugarCurve app — free to download.

Start Free Trial →

Common questions

How much peanut butter is a portion?

USDA's tablespoon is 16 g, about 3.6 g of carbohydrate and 95 kcal at this library's figures; two spoons is a usual serving on toast. Nut butters are as dense in energy as the nuts, so the amount matters more for energy than for carbohydrate. Your dietitian sets what fits your plan.[1] [2]

Is reduced-fat peanut butter better for gestational diabetes?

No, on USDA's figures: it carries 35.7 g of carbohydrate per 100 g against 22.3 g for regular peanut butter, and more sodium, 540 mg against 426 mg. The fat goes down from 51 g to 34 g, but the carbohydrate is the figure that matters more here.[1]

Is powdered peanut butter a good swap?

It is peanut flour with the oil pressed out: USDA lists defatted peanut flour at 34.7 g of carbohydrate, 52 g of protein and 0.55 g of fat per 100 g. Per spoon it carries more carbohydrate and protein than peanut butter and far fewer calories. Read the ingredient list for added sugar and salt.[1]

How do I know if a nut butter has palm oil?

From the ingredient list. EU rules require the specific vegetable origin to follow the words 'vegetable oils', so palm oil is named as palm. The nutrition panel can't tell you, because the added fat looks like the nut's fat.[3]

Keep reading

Important Safety Information

Every pregnancy is different, and gestational diabetes is managed differently depending on your readings, your medication and how far along you are. The ratings and portions on this page are general information — not a diagnosis, a treatment plan or a medical device — and they cannot see your results.

Low blood sugar:
If you take insulin or diabetes medication, eating less carbohydrate than your team planned for can push your blood sugar too low. Treat a reading below 70 mg/dL (3.9 mmol/L), or symptoms such as shaking, sweating, confusion or a racing heart, with fast-acting carbohydrate immediately and retest after 15 minutes. Never use this page as a reason to skip or shrink a meal you were told to eat.
Carbohydrate and ketones:
Cutting carbohydrate hard to force a number down is not safe in pregnancy — it can produce ketones. Published guidance sets a minimum of 175 g of carbohydrate per day in pregnancy. Readings that stay above target for several days need your care team, not a smaller portion.
Medication and insulin:
The portions here are generic and know nothing about your insulin doses, your metformin, or the steroids given to mature your baby's lungs — all of which change how a meal affects you. Never adjust a dose or a mealtime based on this page.
Food safety in pregnancy:
Blood sugar is not the only thing that makes a food suitable while you are pregnant. Some foods with excellent glycemic numbers still carry mercury, vitamin A, listeria or alcohol risks, and those are judged separately from the ratings shown here. Check your national pregnancy food-safety guidance before adding an unfamiliar food.
What these ratings can and cannot tell you:
Glycemic index values, impact ratings and maximum servings are population averages taken from published tables. Two people eating the same food can get very different readings, so your own meter is the only measurement that describes you. Nutrition figures are indicative per 100 g and vary with brand, ripeness and preparation.

Contact your care team the same day if: your readings stay above target for several days; you have a reading below 54 mg/dL (3.0 mmol/L) or needed someone else's help to treat a low; you test positive for ketones; or your baby is moving less than usual. Seek emergency care for confusion, fainting, repeated vomiting, or a low you cannot bring back up.

By using this guide, you agree to our Terms and Conditions. How we write, source and review this content: editorial policy.

Help with every meal, not just this one

SugarCurve plans your week, turns cravings into recipes and shows how your readings respond to what you eat, so following your care team's advice takes less guesswork, day after day.

  • Weekly meal plans
  • Recipes for your cravings
  • Your numbers, in charts
  • Reports for your care team
Try SugarCurve free →

7 days free, then a subscription. Cancel anytime before the trial ends.